stir - Monday, November 2, 2015

stir

stir@jabber.ietf.org

Monday, November 2, 2015< ^ >

Dan York 2 has set the subject to: STIR at IETF92

Room Configuration

Room Occupants

GMT+0
[03:44:37] Meetecho joins the room
[03:53:08] mahoney@nostrum.com joins the room
[03:56:48] Andrew Gallant joins the room
[03:59:45] burn joins the room
[04:00:02] Hala Mowafy joins the room
[04:00:25] Ken Politz joins the room
[04:00:46] <Meetecho> just as a FYI for remote attendees, if you have any issue with remote audio or video, just mention us and we'll be automatically alerted so that we can look into it
[04:01:58] <burn> I will be the jabber relay for the first hour, so if you have something you need spoken at the mic, please precede your comment with 'mic:'
[04:02:17] Dave Crocker joins the room
[04:04:08] Sean Turner joins the room
[04:04:35] Cullen Jennings joins the room
[04:05:35] Julia Kieserman joins the room
[04:08:58] Jim McEachern joins the room
[04:14:27] Bernard Aboba joins the room
[04:18:54] Bernard Aboba leaves the room
[04:19:17] Vinayak Hegde joins the room
[04:20:37] Vinayak Hegde leaves the room
[04:20:54] Srivathsa Sarangapani joins the room
[04:20:54] <burn> Chris Wendt at the mic
[04:21:09] <Dave Crocker> "Probably"?  So the validator of the signature won't know which choice was made by the signer?
[04:21:20] Srivathsa Sarangapani leaves the room
[04:21:41] <burn> do you want that question at the mic?
[04:21:46] <burn> or are you in the room
[04:22:04] Alissa Cooper joins the room
[04:22:15] <burn> I'm the jabber relay -- let me know, Dave
[04:23:07] <Dave Crocker> "Verify twice" is an approach to guessing.  Guessing is not typically considered valid in interoperable protocol specifications.  The specs need to be deterministic.
[04:23:29] <Dave Crocker> @burn, yes.  please use both my postings, together.
[04:23:45] <Dave Crocker> @burn, and btw thanks.
[04:25:17] wolfgang-beck joins the room
[04:25:57] <burn> For any of you remote folks, I am the jabber relay for the first hour, so if you have something you need spoken at the mic, please precede your comment with 'mic:' or something similar
[04:26:40] <burn> Cullen Jennings at mic
[04:27:02] <Jim McEachern> mic: isn't call forwarding another case where the time would be modified by something other than the SBC?
[04:29:08] Jonathan Lennox joins the room
[04:29:39] <burn> Chris Wendt was talking just then at the mic
[04:30:50] <burn> Chris is still hanging out at the mic
[04:31:44] <burn> Adam Roach at the mic
[04:33:48] Hala Mowafy leaves the room
[04:34:40] <burn> When Jon asked if anyone in the room was concerned, there were many head shakes and no one jumping up
[04:34:58] <burn> Sean Turner at the mic
[04:35:01] Mary Barnes joins the room
[04:35:13] <burn> Chris Wendt at teh mic
[04:37:18] Julia Kieserman leaves the room
[04:38:47] rbarnes joins the room
[04:38:57] Mary Barnes joins the room
[04:39:21] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[04:40:09] <rbarnes > doesn't "canon" give you a way out of the issue mr. wendt mentions?  if you find your new peer messes with Date, just include "canon" and verifiers can apply tolerances
[04:40:26] Hala Mowafy joins the room
[04:40:49] <burn> That's Russ Housley at the mic
[04:45:11] Ken Politz leaves the room
[04:45:46] Ken Politz joins the room
[04:47:28] Simon Romano joins the room
[04:47:39] <burn> Richard Barnes at the mic
[04:50:40] <burn> Adam Roach at the mic
[04:51:59] <burn> Cullen Jennings at mic
[04:52:28] <burn> Adam again
[04:54:20] <burn> Chris Wendt at the mic
[04:54:49] rbarnes leaves the room
[04:55:19] <burn> Andrew Allen at the mic
[04:56:27] rbarnes joins the room
[04:57:02] <burn> Remote folks:  can everyone hear okay?
[04:57:11] <Jim McEachern> yes
[04:57:30] <burn> Thanks Jim
[04:58:47] <burn> Have to leave now.  Someone else will take over as jabber relay.
[04:58:50] <Dave Crocker> mic:  DKIM's signature lists the fields it has hashed.
[04:59:09] <burn> hmm, will relay Dave
[05:01:54] burn leaves the room
[05:02:01] <Cullen Jennings> I will be jabber scribe fas Dan needs toleave
[05:04:06] rbarnes leaves the room
[05:08:49] rbarnes joins the room
[05:12:13] rbarnes leaves the room
[05:12:28] rbarnes joins the room
[05:14:32] Ken Politz leaves the room
[05:14:58] Ken Politz joins the room
[05:17:07] Simon Romano leaves the room
[05:19:42] <Cullen Jennings> Barens, Chris, Sean agreed to do review
[05:19:52] Simon Romano joins the room
[05:23:24] Jim McEachern leaves the room
[05:24:46] Jonathan Lennox leaves the room
[05:33:05] John Barnhill joins the room
[05:33:13] rbarnes leaves the room
[05:34:41] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[05:35:50] Jonathan Lennox joins the room
[05:38:03] rbarnes joins the room
[05:40:57] Mary Barnes joins the room
[05:44:04] Mary Barnes joins the room
[05:44:04] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[05:45:56] rbarnes leaves the room
[05:47:44] Dave Crocker leaves the room
[05:48:17] rbarnes joins the room
[05:48:41] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[05:49:44] rbarnes wonders where this discussion is going
[05:53:21] Jonathan Lennox leaves the room
[05:54:10] rbarnes leaves the room
[05:56:44] mahoney@nostrum.com leaves the room
[05:56:47] Ken Politz leaves the room
[05:56:51] Sean Turner leaves the room
[05:57:09] Meetecho leaves the room
[05:57:21] Cullen Jennings leaves the room
[05:57:27] Hala Mowafy leaves the room
[05:57:30] Andrew Gallant leaves the room
[05:57:34] John Barnhill leaves the room
[05:58:44] wolfgang-beck leaves the room: Disconnected: Replaced by new connection
[05:58:47] wolfgang-beck joins the room
[06:03:50] Simon Romano leaves the room
[06:06:19] rbarnes joins the room
[06:10:26] rbarnes leaves the room
[06:11:16] Alissa Cooper leaves the room
[06:15:02] wolfgang-beck leaves the room: Disconnected: connection closed
[06:16:10] wolfgang-beck joins the room
[06:18:47] Mary Barnes joins the room
[06:20:54] rbarnes joins the room
[06:22:46] rbarnes leaves the room
[06:24:12] Sean Turner joins the room
[06:26:16] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[06:27:51] rbarnes joins the room
[06:29:06] rbarnes leaves the room
[06:29:12] rbarnes joins the room
[06:29:32] rbarnes leaves the room
[06:29:33] Mary Barnes joins the room
[06:31:18] wolfgang-beck leaves the room: Disconnected: Replaced by new connection
[06:31:18] wolfgang-beck joins the room
[06:32:05] Sean Turner leaves the room: Replaced by new connection
[06:35:27] Mary Barnes joins the room
[06:35:40] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[06:50:59] rbarnes joins the room
[06:51:01] rbarnes leaves the room
[06:51:08] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[06:55:36] Mary Barnes joins the room
[07:00:18] Alissa Cooper joins the room
[07:01:49] Alissa Cooper leaves the room
[07:01:49] Alissa Cooper joins the room
[07:03:55] Alissa Cooper leaves the room
[07:22:57] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[07:23:00] Mary Barnes joins the room
[07:48:17] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[08:12:54] Mary Barnes joins the room
[08:13:47] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[08:23:36] Mary Barnes joins the room
[08:30:04] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[08:31:45] Mary Barnes joins the room
[08:53:32] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[08:54:22] Mary Barnes joins the room
[08:57:21] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[08:57:58] Mary Barnes joins the room
[09:06:59] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[09:10:08] Mary Barnes joins the room
[09:33:46] wolfgang-beck leaves the room
[09:34:12] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[09:44:50] Mary Barnes joins the room
[09:45:53] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[09:47:36] Mary Barnes joins the room
[10:24:31] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[10:24:31] Mary Barnes joins the room
[10:24:31] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[12:14:08] Mary Barnes joins the room
[14:40:38] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[21:34:16] Mary Barnes joins the room
[21:35:20] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[21:37:31] Mary Barnes joins the room
[22:04:57] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[22:05:29] Mary Barnes joins the room
[22:07:38] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[22:32:06] Mary Barnes joins the room
[22:45:57] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[22:46:52] Mary Barnes joins the room
[22:48:59] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[23:03:04] Mary Barnes joins the room
[23:11:32] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[23:13:28] Mary Barnes joins the room
[23:34:00] Mary Barnes leaves the room
[23:35:52] Mary Barnes joins the room