[08:39:51] dseomn joins the room [08:39:52] Tobia Castaldi joins the room [08:53:20] Paolo Saviano joins the room [08:59:15] Slide 1: SIDR  Working  Group   [08:59:38] lepinski joins the room [08:59:44] Welcome [09:00:53] Slide 2: Classic  Note  Well   [09:00:54] Slide 1: SIDR  Working  Group   [09:01:03] Slide 2: Classic  Note  Well   [09:01:04] lepinski joins the room [09:01:11] lepinski leaves the room [09:01:13] Slide 3: Note Well (Experimental) [09:01:18] Slide 4: Resources   [09:01:34] lepinski leaves the room [09:01:49] Naveen K Lakshman joins the room [09:02:25] Wes George joins the room [09:02:37] leo.vegoda joins the room [09:02:57] lepinski joins the room [09:03:11] Slide 5: Administrivia   [09:03:11] bje joins the room [09:03:17] lepinski leaves the room [09:03:20] randy joins the room [09:03:24] Slide 6: WG  Dra\  Status   [09:03:40] bje leaves the room [09:03:46] bje joins the room [09:03:58] Benno Overeinder joins the room [09:04:28] lepinski joins the room [09:04:48] Byron joins the room [09:05:12] lepinski leaves the room [09:05:32] Carlos Martinez Cagnazzo joins the room [09:06:00] Administrivia & Draft status [09:06:00] lepinski joins the room [09:06:54] WG Draft Status on screen [09:07:18] lepinski leaves the room [09:07:19] FYI, a Meetecho session is avalaible at http://www.meetecho.com/ietf89/sidr [09:07:24] sean.turner@jabber.psg.com joins the room [09:07:27] A synchronized view of the official jabber room, the current slides being presented and an audio/video stream from the room is made available [09:07:31] lepinski joins the room [09:07:46] Slide 7: WG  Dra\  Status   [09:08:10] lepinski leaves the room [09:08:14] Leo Vegoda joins the room [09:08:25] bje leaves the room [09:08:43] Benno Overeinder 2 joins the room [09:09:02] lepinski joins the room [09:09:27] lepinski leaves the room [09:09:40] Slide 9: WG Draft Summary [09:09:41] lepinski joins the room [09:09:51] Slide 10: Agenda   [09:10:08] Presentation stopped [09:10:12] lepinski leaves the room [09:10:33] Slide 1: dra$-­‐huston-­‐sidr-­‐rfc6490- [09:10:35] Slide 2: dra$-­‐huston-­‐sidr-­‐rfc6490- [09:10:47] RFC6490bis 0915-0930 Resource Certificate PKI (RPKI) Trust Anchor Locator draft-huston-sidr-rfc6490-bis-01.txt http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-huston-sidr-rfc6490-bis [09:10:52] Slide 3: RFC6490   [09:11:12] lepinski joins the room [09:11:24] Slide 4: dra$-­‐ieW-­‐sidr-­‐mulSple-­� [09:11:48] lepinski leaves the room [09:12:20] Slide 5 [09:12:34] Slide 6 [09:12:44] lepinski joins the room [09:13:33] Benno Overeinder 2 leaves the room [09:14:43] lepinski leaves the room [09:15:08] Hosnieh Rafiee joins the room [09:15:11] lepinski joins the room [09:15:48] Naveen K Lakshman leaves the room [09:16:04] lepinski leaves the room [09:16:43] lepinski joins the room [09:17:55] Slide 1: Fixing an OID problem in RFC6485 [09:18:06] lepinski leaves the room [09:18:15] lepinski joins the room [09:18:18] Rob Austein on the mike [09:19:44] Tim Bruinzeels on the mike [09:19:44] lepinski leaves the room [09:19:54] Randy Bush on the mike [09:20:07] Amreesh Phokeer joins the room [09:20:41] lepinski joins the room [09:21:15] lepinski leaves the room [09:21:15] Now on [09:21:17] Fixing a point problem in OID with RFC6485. 0930-0945 Clarifying RPKI use of CMS SignerInfo draft-michaelson-signerinfo-01.txt http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-michaelson-signerinfo [09:21:43] Slide 2 [09:21:54] sean.turner@jabber.psg.com leaves the room [09:22:13] lepinski joins the room [09:22:25] Slide 3 [09:23:14] Rob Austein on the mike [09:23:32] lepinski leaves the room [09:24:26] lepinski joins the room [09:26:57] Stewart on the mike; suggestion how to proceed with the document & errata [09:27:28] Rob Austein presenting [09:27:30] no slide on the screen [09:27:48] should a router cert have more than one ASn? [09:28:30] Steve Kent on mike [09:28:50] Randy on mike [09:29:51] Iñigo Ortiz de Urbina Cazenave joins the room [09:30:15] Rob: one key, one certficiate, done [09:30:22] sean.turner@jabber.psg.com joins the room [09:30:26] Mat Lepinksi on the mike [09:30:43] sean.turner@jabber.psg.com leaves the room: Replaced by new connection [09:30:45] sean.turner@jabber.psg.com joins the room [09:30:53] Randy on the mike [09:31:47] Jeff Haas on the mike [09:33:39] omnibudsgeek: Randy Bush e) RPKI Validation - Revisited 1015-1030 RPKI Validation Reconsidered draft-huston-rpki-validation-01.txt http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-huston-rpki-validation [09:33:55] sean.turner@jabber.psg.com leaves the room: Replaced by new connection [09:34:02] no slides on [09:34:53] Steve Kent on mike [09:36:18] Sandy (chair hat off) on the mike [09:36:56] russ joins the room [09:37:22] Alia Atlas joins the room [09:37:41] Juan-Pedro Cerezo Martin joins the room [09:38:58] Slide 1: RPKI Validation Revisited [09:39:31] jpc joins the room [09:39:40] randy leaves the room [09:39:51] Randy Bush joins the room [09:40:18] Slide 2: Motivation [09:41:06] bjo joins the room [09:44:01] Slide 3: RPKI Validation [09:44:42] Slide 4 [09:46:01] slide 6 [09:46:23] slide 7 [09:46:40] Slide 7: Why  is  this?   [09:46:41] cur joins the room [09:47:18] Slide 8: The  Seman cs  of  an  RPKI [09:48:44] Slide 9: The Semantics of... [09:49:17] Slide 9: The Semantics of... [09:49:35] Slide 10: The Semantics of an RPKI Certificate [09:49:42] Slide 11: So  what?   [09:51:21] Slide 12: An  Alterna ve  Approach   [09:52:40] Slide 13: An  Alterna ve  Validity  ques [09:52:46] Alia Atlas joins the room [09:52:55] Slide 14 [09:52:59] Alia Atlas leaves the room [09:54:08] cur leaves the room [09:55:37] Slide 17: A revised Local Cache [09:55:47] Slide 18 [09:56:33] Slide 19 [09:57:47] randy bush on the mike [10:00:03] rob austein on the mike [10:04:26] doug montgomery on mike [10:11:52] david still on the mike [10:12:50] Iñigo Ortiz de Urbina Cazenave leaves the room [10:15:52] steve bellovin on the mike [10:17:20] leo.vegoda leaves the room [10:18:45] tim bruijnzeels on the mike [10:19:55] jayb@jabber.org joins the room [10:21:34] bjo leaves the room [10:22:40] steve kent on the mike [10:24:21] Slide 10 [10:28:35] queue for mike is closed [10:28:41] warren kumari on the mike [10:29:34] robert kisteleki on the mike [10:29:40] Randy Bush leaves the room [10:31:01] carlos martinez on the mike [10:32:05] wes hardaker on the mike [10:33:10] bjo joins the room [10:36:21] SLURM 1030-1045 Simplified Local internet nUmber Resource Management with the RPKI draft-dseomn-sidr-slurm-00.txt http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-dseomn-sidr-slurm Presenter: David Mandelberg [10:36:40] Slide 1: Simplified Local internet nUmber Resourc [10:36:43] Slide 2: Use Case [10:36:47] Slide 3: Position in the Relying Party Stack [10:37:12] is audio wonky for everyone or just me? [10:37:36] audio better now? [10:38:14] slide 7 [10:38:19] Slide 4: Components [10:38:45] slide 8 [10:39:00] it briefly came back [10:39:04] slide 9/questions [10:39:08] but is just the occasional pop or hiss [10:39:20] there it is [10:39:31] seems fine now [10:39:34] thanks! [10:39:50] rob austein on mike [10:40:53] Benno Overeinder leaves the room: Disconnected: Replaced by new connection [10:41:14] Leo Vegoda leaves the room [10:41:41] Slide 8: Example SLURM File [10:43:27] Benno Overeinder joins the room [10:44:03] chris morrow on mike [10:45:27] tim bruijnzeels on the mike [10:46:02] rob austein on the mike [10:46:12] declan on the mike [10:46:18] just a memo for remote participants: a Meetecho session is avalaible at http://www.meetecho.com/ietf89/sidr [10:46:27] (declan ma) [10:46:39] randy bush on the mike [10:47:12] wes george on hte mike [10:48:36] randy bush on the mike [10:49:48] Presentation stopped [10:49:59] Slide 1: Resource Transfer Protocol and Transfer [10:50:07] Current presenter: David Mandelberg [10:50:07] Slide 1: Resource Transfer Protocol and Transfer [10:50:10] Slide 2: Background [10:50:46] Slide 3: Context [10:50:50] Slide 4: Terminology: Actors [10:51:26] Slide 5: Terminology: Transfer Types [10:51:50] Slide 6: High-level Overview [10:53:00] Slide 7: Protocol Requirements [10:53:40] Slide 8: Scenario [10:53:51] Slide 9: TAO [10:54:23] Slide 10: Unused INR Transfer Example: Start [10:54:39] Slide 11: Unused INR Transfer Example: Simultaneou [10:55:06] Slide 12: Unused INR Transfer Example: Recipient r [10:55:19] Slide 13: Live INR Transfer Example: Start [10:55:38] Slide 14: Live INR Transfer Example: Simultaneous [10:55:46] Slide 15: Live INR Transfer Example: Recipient rec [10:56:11] Slide 16: Live INR Transfer Example: Source relinq [10:56:49] Slide 17: Recap [10:57:17] Slide 18: Questions? [10:58:14] SKI is not identity [10:58:30] Slide 8: Scenario [10:58:53] @Byron proxy to mike? [10:59:17] Yes, if it doesn't come up before you get there [10:59:38] thanks [11:00:22] Doug Montgomery joins the room [11:00:28] Doug Montgomery leaves the room [11:00:29] Alia Atlas leaves the room [11:00:32] Doug Montgomery joins the room [11:01:27] Slide 13: Live INR Transfer Example: Start [11:01:34] @Byron, answer ok? [11:01:37] Eve's SKI is more of a concern - does that mean the resources MUST transfer into that certificate? [11:01:47] it needs clarification in the doc, it's not a blocker [11:01:51] I'll take it to list [11:02:10] Leo Vegoda joins the room [11:02:31] Randy Bush joins the room [11:03:24] thank you [11:03:41] Presentation stopped [11:03:42] I appreciate the remote voices :) [11:03:43] slm joins the room [11:04:01] Slide 1: [11:04:02] You are welcome! Sandy is pushing me :-) [11:04:06] Slide 2: [11:04:15] Slide 3: [11:04:19] Slide 4: [11:05:09] Slide 5: [11:05:10] why do you think you might need to "have a single router key for entire AS"? [11:05:45] Slide 6: [11:05:49] Slide 7: [11:05:59] Amreesh Phokeer leaves the room [11:06:59] Slide 8: [11:07:03] Slide 9: [11:07:05] Slide 10: [11:07:08] Slide 11: [11:07:08] slm, did you want to interrupt or wait for end? [11:07:54] Slide 12: [11:07:56] Slide 13: [11:08:03] Slide 14: [11:08:18] Slide 14: [11:08:19] Doug Montgomery leaves the room [11:08:35] Current presenter: George [11:08:36] Slide 14: [11:08:37] Slide 15: [11:08:41] Slide 16: [11:08:55] Doug Montgomery joins the room [11:09:14] Slide 17: [11:09:16] Slide 18: [11:09:27] Slide 19: [11:09:31] Slide 20: [11:09:33] Slide 21: [11:09:51] Slide 22: [11:10:06] Slide 23: [11:10:19] Hosnieh Rafiee leaves the room [11:10:39] Slide 24: [11:11:24] Doug Montgomery leaves the room [11:11:34] Slide 25: [11:11:46] Doug Montgomery joins the room [11:11:57] Slide 26: [11:12:12] Slide 27: [11:12:22] Slide 28: [11:12:33] no need for interrupt of presenation, was asking question of other jabber participant, not the speaker [11:12:41] Slide 29: [11:12:57] Slide 30: [11:13:02] Doug Montgomery leaves the room [11:13:27] Slide 31: [11:13:43] Slide 32: [11:13:52] Jahangir Hossain joins the room [11:13:56] Slide 33: [11:14:14] Slide 34: [11:14:25] Slide 35: [11:16:13] Slide 36: [11:16:19] Slide 37: [11:16:20] Slide 38: [11:16:22] Slide 39: [11:16:23] Slide 40: [11:16:54] Slide 41: [11:17:09] Slide 42: [11:17:21] Slide 43: [11:17:37] Doug Montgomery joins the room [11:18:40] Slide 44: [11:18:44] Slide 45: [11:18:50] Slide 46: [11:20:01] Slide 47: [11:20:21] rob austein on the mike [11:20:22] russ leaves the room [11:21:23] rcynic *does* fetch other peoples' repositories as the same user - I would think that overwriting someone else's ROAs might count as bad :-) [11:22:19] Leo Vegoda leaves the room [11:22:31] russ joins the room [11:23:26] carlos martinez on the mike [11:23:32] Randy Bush leaves the room [11:23:42] Presentation stopped [11:24:00] Slide 1: Implementing RPKI-based origin validatio [11:24:03] Slide 2: Why and who? [11:24:25] Current presenter: Fabian [11:24:26] Slide 2: Why and who? [11:24:44] Slide 3: ABSTRACT [11:24:51] Slide 4: Roles [11:25:44] Slide 5: Objective [11:26:15] Slide 6: Planning [11:26:44] Slide 7: Deployment [11:26:48] russ leaves the room [11:27:37] Slide 8: Training and RPKI signing event [11:28:11] Randy Bush joins the room [11:28:23] Slide 9: Outcome and post-event activities [11:29:03] Wes George leaves the room [11:29:12] Slide 10: Lessons learned and best practices [11:30:07] Slide 11: IMPACT – LAC REGION [11:30:29] Slide 12: IMPACT – COMPARATIVE [11:30:31] Slide 13: Thanks [11:30:43] Ruediger Volk on the mike [11:31:34] alvaro on the mike [11:33:04] session closed [11:33:04] Doug Montgomery leaves the room [11:33:10] Benno Overeinder leaves the room [11:33:10] Presentation stopped [11:33:14] slm leaves the room [11:33:21] Randy Bush leaves the room [11:33:24] hi all [11:33:27] Carlos Martinez Cagnazzo leaves the room [11:33:30] this session is over [11:33:34] Juan-Pedro Cerezo Martin leaves the room [11:33:43] we are going to close the meetecho session too [11:33:55] thanks all [11:34:20] bjo leaves the room [11:34:25] the recording of the session will be available at http:///www.meetecho.com/ietf89/recordings see you next time on Meetecho [11:34:30] slm joins the room [11:34:40] jpc leaves the room [11:34:47] Thanks to all .. [11:35:00] Byron leaves the room [11:35:07] jayb@jabber.org leaves the room: offline [11:35:09] Jahangir Hossain leaves the room [11:35:13] Paolo Saviano leaves the room [11:35:45] Tobia Castaldi leaves the room [11:36:06] slm leaves the room [11:38:01] lepinski leaves the room [12:03:03] dseomn leaves the room [12:30:52] slm joins the room [12:41:44] russ joins the room [12:53:40] russ leaves the room [13:04:32] mux joins the room [13:04:42] mux leaves the room [13:05:23] Benno Overeinder joins the room [13:06:31] slm leaves the room [13:09:56] Doug Montgomery joins the room [13:10:41] Benno Overeinder leaves the room [13:20:42] Carlos Martinez Cagnazzo joins the room [13:29:07] slm joins the room [13:41:11] Doug Montgomery leaves the room [13:42:09] Doug Montgomery joins the room [13:58:22] david joins the room [13:59:22] Doug Montgomery leaves the room [14:00:16] slm leaves the room [14:09:03] Carlos Martinez Cagnazzo leaves the room [14:21:29] Doug Montgomery joins the room [14:21:39] Doug Montgomery leaves the room [14:34:54] david leaves the room [14:35:32] david joins the room [14:39:20] david leaves the room [14:39:23] david joins the room [14:44:17] Carlos Martinez Cagnazzo joins the room [14:44:58] Carlos Martinez Cagnazzo leaves the room [15:01:38] slm joins the room [16:05:47] slm leaves the room [16:35:58] slm joins the room [17:30:59] david leaves the room [17:31:21] david joins the room [18:00:59] slm leaves the room [18:24:21] slm joins the room [18:45:51] slm leaves the room [23:08:36] slm joins the room [23:15:16] david leaves the room [23:15:46] david joins the room