IETF
regent
regext@jabber.ietf.org
Thursday, July 28, 2022< ^ >
Meetecho has set the subject to: REGEXT IETF113
Room Configuration
Room Occupants

GMT+0
[21:01:27] Yoshiro Yoneya joins the room
[21:21:09] <zulipbot> (Antoin Verschuren) Welcome!
[21:21:43] <zulipbot> (Richard Wilhelm) check check check
[21:23:46] <zulipbot> (Richard Wilhelm) so early for Yoneya-san and so late for Stephane!
[21:25:31] <zulipbot> (Stéphane Bortzmeyer) Indeed, I hate remote meetings (but it would be worse if IETF were in California)
[21:26:14] <Yoshiro Yoneya> Good evening all!
[21:26:18] <zulipbot> (Antoin Verschuren) Well, almost midnight, sleep late tomorrow ;-)
[21:26:31] <zulipbot> (Heather Flanagan) Well, next time is in London. Which means it will be crazy early for me for some of it, but doable.
[21:26:44] <zulipbot> (Andrew Newton) Hello
[21:26:57] <zulipbot> (James Galvin) good morning Yoneya-son
[21:27:13] <zulipbot> (Mario Loffredo) Hi everybody
[21:27:16] <Yoshiro Yoneya> I've living totally reversed day and night week.
[21:27:52] <zulipbot> (Heather Flanagan) Ciao, Mario!
[21:29:04] <zulipbot> (Richard Wilhelm) But Yokohama was announced for next March... so relief is in sight for you ;-)
[21:29:26] <zulipbot> (Richard Wilhelm) Yoneya-san, that is... not sure if that helps or hurts Mario
[21:29:48] <Yoshiro Yoneya> Yeah, Yokohama is my home town :-)
[21:30:18] <zulipbot> (Mario Loffredo) @Heather, Ciao :-)
[21:35:35] <zulipbot> (James Gould) Go Rick!
[21:35:50] <zulipbot> (Richard Wilhelm) doc is open... anyone feel free to put stuff in or fix stuff that I mess up
[21:49:40] <zulipbot> (James Galvin) car
[21:49:53] <zulipbot> (Andrew Newton) Does that hold true with EVs?
[21:52:12] <zulipbot> (Peter Koch) not representing an ICANN contracted party, I still sympathize with Rick's concerns
[21:52:54] <zulipbot> (Stéphane Bortzmeyer) @Peter But why is it different than all the other RFCs that are used in ICANN contracts?
[21:55:10] <zulipbot> (Peter Koch) not sure about "all the other RFCs", but to the best of my knowledge they point to protocol specifications
[21:56:27] <zulipbot> (Stéphane Bortzmeyer) The best example is RFC 8499 (nt
[21:56:40] <zulipbot> (Stéphane Bortzmeyer) (not a protocol specification)
[21:59:21] <zulipbot> (Peter Koch) 8499 has its own set of issues, but at least it is 'only' a BCP and does not use normative language
[22:00:27] <zulipbot> (Peter Koch) (except for a quote from RFC 4035)
[22:09:09] <zulipbot> (James Gould) I just want to ensure that the versioning of policy identifiers can still be registered
[22:15:18] <zulipbot> (Andrew Newton) It exists so a client can know which query parameters to use when sending requests.
[22:15:19] <zulipbot> (James Gould) Ensure that identifiers like icann_rdap_response_profile_0 and icann_rdap_technical_implementation_guide_0 can continue to be registered, since versioning is not an RDAP Extension Registry feature.
[22:15:48] <zulipbot> (Richard Wilhelm) I think that as long as they are unique... they can be registered.  Fair?
[22:17:50] <zulipbot> (James Gould) That sounds fair to me, as long as the proposal doesn't disallow versioning of these type of identifiers.
[22:18:03] <zulipbot> (Andrew Newton) "hint" was bad language. :)
[22:19:56] <zulipbot> (Jasdip Singh) On similar lines, the NRO RDAP Profile for RIRs also has an extension registered for conformance among the RIRs.
[22:20:09] <zulipbot> (James Gould) Correct the policy / profile identifiers don't define structure but the data that would be returned in the structure.
[22:20:22] <zulipbot> (Andrew Newton) I support the chairs proposal.
[22:21:25] <zulipbot> (James Gould) For draft-ietf-regext-rdap-redacted, we would register "redacted", which will be used for the rdapConformance value and the response member of the extension.
[22:22:02] <zulipbot> (Jasdip Singh) That's alright. :)
[22:23:40] <zulipbot> (Andrew Newton) Yes! Thanks to the Chairs!
[22:23:47] <Yoshiro Yoneya> clap!
[22:24:10] <zulipbot> (Jasdip Singh) +1
[22:24:10] <zulipbot> (Tom Harrison) +1
[22:24:52] <zulipbot> (George Michaelson) redacted_level_0  :-)
[22:27:46] <zulipbot> (James Gould) Thanks everyone!
[22:27:46] <zulipbot> (Mario Loffredo) me too
[22:27:59] <zulipbot> (Jody Kolker) thanks everyone!
[22:28:12] <zulipbot> (Mario Loffredo) Thanks all. Good night
[22:28:44] Yoshiro Yoneya leaves the room