pwe3 - Wednesday, 1 August 2012

pwe3

pwe3@jabber.ietf.org

Wednesday, 1 August 2012< ^ >

Room Configuration

GMT+0
[00:02:15] Andy Malis joins the room
[00:02:48] <YJS> starting
[00:03:04] <YJS> Agenda bash, WG Agenda and Status
[00:03:11] <YJS> David not at the meeting
[00:03:22] <YJS> slight agenda change
[00:03:34] <YJS> OF draft has been moved to the end of the session
[00:04:14] <YJS> goals and milestones
[00:04:18] <YJS> Four new RFCs since last IETF:
[00:04:35] <YJS> RFC Ed Queue:
draft-ietf-pwe3-redundancy and draft-ietf-pwe3-cbit-negotiation
[00:04:52] <YJS> with IESG:
PW redundancy drafts, VCCV Implementation Survey Results, Ethernet OAM Interworking
[00:05:18] <YJS> P2MP PW Requirements sent back to WG
[00:06:14] <YJS> others: iccp
on agenda, status-reduction expired,
[00:06:35] Stewart Bryant joins the room
[00:06:44] <YJS> mpls-tp-oam-config new version will be submitted,
[00:07:04] <YJS> vccv-for-gal scope needs to be reduced (lots of comments after LC)
[00:07:28] <YJS> Luca just walked in
[00:07:42] <YJS> says that needs to refresh status reduction
[00:07:54] <YJS> also need LC on ICCP
[00:08:00] <YJS> mpls-tp-ms-pw will be refreshed
[00:08:22] <YJS> reminder to address IESG comments in timelu ashion
[00:09:18] Matt Bocci leaves the room
[00:09:18] <YJS> Stewart : best time to comment is before IESG chat
[00:09:28] <YJS> Virtual Circuit Connectivity Verification version 2 (VCCV2) - Tom Nadeau (and me?)
[00:09:51] <YJS> draft-nadeau-pwe3-vccv2-00
[00:19:56] <YJS> Himanshu: TTL can be used for non-CW PWs ?
[00:19:59] <YJS> Yaakov: yes
[00:21:35] <YJS> Shahram: in favor of a bis
[00:25:25] <YJS> Andy : a short document would be great
[00:25:38] <YJS> Stewart: short, and then you can do a rewrite if you want
[00:26:04] <YJS> Matthew: who wants a brief document just for CC modes (existing docs remain) ?
[00:26:08] <YJS> 3
[00:26:18] <YJS> who would prefer a comprehensive doc ?
[00:26:34] <YJS> 6
[00:26:47] <YJS> 1 doesn't care
[00:26:59] <YJS> underwhelming portion of the room
[00:27:10] <YJS> PW Congestion Considerations - Yaakov STEIN
[00:29:34] <scott.mansfield> PWE3 as a workign group has a long-standing commitment to deal with the congestion problem. David Black thinks this work belongs in PWE3.
[00:41:43] <scott.mansfield> A request to accept this item as a PWE3 work item with the goal of producing an informational RFC.
[00:41:48] <scott.mansfield> David Black...
[00:46:37] <YJS> PW endpoint fast failure protection - Yimin SHEN
[00:46:45] <YJS> draft-shen-pwe3-endpoint-fast-protection-02
[00:47:20] <YJS> local repair is fast but temp, while global repair is the opposite
[00:48:08] <YJS> need LDP extension
[00:49:55] <YJS> skipped examples
[00:50:00] <YJS> addressed all comments
[00:50:51] <YJS> Transporting PTP messages (1588) over MPLS Networks - Shahram DAVARI
[00:51:00] <YJS> draft-ietf-tictoc-1588overmpls-02
[00:51:18] <YJS> active in TICTOC WG
[00:52:26] <YJS> showing support of different clock types
[00:59:23] <YJS> Transparent SDH/SONET over Packet - Gert MANHOUDT
[00:59:30] <YJS> draft-manhoudt-pwe3-tsop-00
[00:59:48] <YJS> RFC4842 (CEP) already does this, but this is simpler
[01:02:15] <YJS> basically extending SAToP to STM signals
[01:06:55] <YJS> Pseudowire redundancy on S-PE - Jie DONG
[01:07:16] <YJS> draft-dong-pwe3-redundancy-spe-02
[01:08:05] <YJS> (on previous talk - need to liaise to ITU-T SG15 before September plenary meeting) <for the notes>
[01:10:27] <YJS> complementary to redundancy-bit draft
[01:10:36] <YJS> not many people have read
[01:10:51] <YJS> ICCP extension for MSP - Yuxia MA
[01:11:00] <YJS> draft-hao-pwe3-iccp-extension-for-msp-03
[01:15:20] <YJS> Definition of P2MP PW TLV for LSP-Ping Mechanisms - Sami BOUTROS
[01:15:28] <YJS> draft-jain-pwe3-p2mp-pw-lsp-ping-00
[01:15:55] <YJS> defines LSP-ping FEC element for P2MP
[01:16:21] <YJS> FEC 130
[01:17:10] <YJS> and also FEC 131
[01:20:20] <YJS> MPLS-TP Pseudowire Configuration using OpenFlow 1.3 - Andrew MCLACHLAN/David MEYER
[01:20:27] <YJS> draft-medved-pwe3-of-config-01
[01:22:59] <YJS> motivation - really wanted to do something programmatic having to do with PWs
[01:30:54] scott.mansfield leaves the room
[01:30:59] <YJS> done
[01:31:16] Stewart Bryant leaves the room
[01:31:20] Andy Malis leaves the room
[01:32:17] Andy Malis joins the room
[01:32:18] Andy Malis leaves the room
[01:32:51] scott.mansfield joins the room
[01:35:41] YJS leaves the room
[01:42:55] scott.mansfield leaves the room
[07:07:34] Stewart Bryant joins the room
[07:43:31] Stewart Bryant leaves the room
[07:54:59] Stewart Bryant joins the room
[08:56:57] Stewart Bryant leaves the room
[14:07:44] Stewart Bryant joins the room
[15:10:03] Stewart Bryant leaves the room
[15:59:10] Stewart Bryant joins the room
[16:13:32] scott.mansfield joins the room
[16:44:55] scott.mansfield leaves the room
[18:23:51] Stewart Bryant leaves the room
[19:18:13] Stewart Bryant joins the room
[19:51:34] Stewart Bryant leaves the room
[20:29:19] Stewart Bryant joins the room
[20:34:46] Stewart Bryant leaves the room
[20:55:57] Stewart Bryant joins the room
[22:00:52] Stewart Bryant leaves the room