netconf - Tuesday, July 22, 2014

netconf

netconf@jabber.ietf.org

Tuesday, July 22, 2014< ^ >

Bill has set the subject to: NETCONF meeting at IETF-81

Room Configuration

Room Occupants

GMT+0
[17:27:29] Bert Wijnen joins the room
[17:45:37] Bert Wijnen leaves the room
[18:00:55] Bert Wijnen joins the room
[18:43:59] Bert Wijnen leaves the room
[18:44:37] Bert Wijnen joins the room
[19:38:20] Bert Wijnen leaves the room
[19:58:09] Bert Wijnen joins the room
[20:13:33] Bert Wijnen leaves the room
[20:13:37] Bert Wijnen joins the room
[20:19:39] Bert Wijnen leaves the room
[20:32:05] Bert Wijnen joins the room
[20:32:42] Bert Wijnen leaves the room
[20:35:37] room feed joins the room
[20:36:06] slide monitor joins the room
[20:38:01] Bert Wijnen joins the room
[20:38:07] bpenfield joins the room
[20:38:41] Paolo Saviano joins the room
[20:38:50] Jürgen Schönwälder joins the room
[20:39:23] tonyhain joins the room
[20:39:29] <Bert Wijnen> if anyone has trouble not hearing us on the audio, then pls holler here
[20:39:51] <tonyhain> the sound was fine, but now someone is messing with it and there is a loud hum
[20:41:17] Sudhir Pendse joins the room
[20:41:17] Robert Raszuk joins the room
[20:41:56] Giles Heron joins the room
[20:43:05] Praveen Kumar joins the room
[20:43:32] Praveen Kumar leaves the room
[20:44:32] Dean Bogdanovic joins the room
[20:44:42] Robert_Raszuk joins the room
[20:44:51] Robert_Raszuk leaves the room
[20:45:04] ida leung joins the room
[20:46:37] <ida leung> The slides look out of focus for me
[20:48:02] ida leung leaves the room
[20:48:09] <Giles Heron> they're fine for me Ida. But then I'm reading them on my own laptop ;)
[20:48:14] ida leung joins the room
[20:48:23] <Giles Heron> the audio sucks rocks though (hardly the first time @ this IETF)
[20:48:34] <Giles Heron> lots of hiss
[20:48:54] alessandro amirante joins the room
[20:51:30] <Dean Bogdanovic> video is great
[20:53:05] <Giles Heron> there's video?
[20:53:12] <Dean Bogdanovic> yes,
[20:53:22] <Dean Bogdanovic> on meetecho, you can see the presenter
[20:54:04] <ida leung> I use meetecho but the slides are all out of focus for me
[20:54:05] <Robert Raszuk> Yep you can see presenter but slides quality is rather poor ...
[20:54:25] Mikael Abrahamsson joins the room
[20:55:18] <Dean Bogdanovic> same for me with slides
[20:55:34] Praveen Kumar joins the room
[20:55:38] <ida leung> ok, so not another new pair of glasses for me =)
[20:57:47] <Bert Wijnen> slides can be found here: https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/90/materials.html#wg-netconf
[21:00:14] <Bert Wijnen> does/did that help?
[21:01:19] <Bert Wijnen> slide 8
[21:01:32] <Bert Wijnen> is coming up now
[21:01:34] The Real Giles Heron joins the room
[21:02:15] <Bert Wijnen> this is the current slideset: http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/90/slides/slides-90-netconf-10.pdf
[21:02:24] <Bert Wijnen> slide 9
[21:02:40] tom nadeau joins the room
[21:02:49] <Bert Wijnen> slide 10
[21:03:38] The Real Giles Heron leaves the room
[21:04:01] bpenfield leaves the room
[21:04:21] <Bert Wijnen> Kent speaking, slideset: http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/90/slides/slides-90-netconf-2.pptx
[21:04:41] tom nadeau leaves the room
[21:04:52] tom nadeau joins the room
[21:05:17] Giles Heron leaves the room
[21:05:46] Giles Heron joins the room
[21:05:50] <ida leung> thx
[21:06:36] <Bert Wijnen> slide 5
[21:06:56] <Bert Wijnen> slide 7
[21:07:37] <Bert Wijnen> slide 8
[21:07:43] <Bert Wijnen> open issues
[21:08:05] <Bert Wijnen> slide 4 has details on forst isseue
[21:08:29] <Bert Wijnen> slide 8 issues: issue 2
[21:08:40] <Bert Wijnen> slide 5 for details
[21:08:54] <Bert Wijnen> issue 3 (slide 8)
[21:09:00] <Bert Wijnen> slide 8
[21:09:14] <Bert Wijnen> issue 4
[21:09:55] <Bert Wijnen> slide 9, issue 5
[21:10:15] <Dean Bogdanovic> Bert, you are pretty good. Could work in court :-)
[21:10:23] <Bert Wijnen> issue 6
[21:10:37] <Bert Wijnen> Dean: not really
[21:10:40] Joe Clarke joins the room
[21:10:47] <Bert Wijnen> slide 6 for details
[21:11:28] <Bert Wijnen> slide 9 issue 7
[21:12:24] <Bert Wijnen> slide 10
[21:12:28] <Bert Wijnen> questions?
[21:12:50] <Bert Wijnen> slide 8 again
[21:14:05] Kiminori Nagoya joins the room
[21:14:29] Kiminori Nagoya leaves the room
[21:14:55] Robert Raszuk leaves the room
[21:15:35] <Bert Wijnen> sorry had to deal with nluesheets
[21:15:41] <Bert Wijnen> now on slide 9
[21:16:45] <Bert Wijnen> s/nluesheets/bluesheets/
[21:16:59] Robert Raszuk joins the room
[21:19:25] <tom nadeau> Cage Match!
[21:22:18] Robert Raszuk leaves the room
[21:22:59] <Bert Wijnen> slide 7
[21:23:13] <Bert Wijnen> Cage Match would be nice, no?
[21:23:33] tonyhain leaves the room
[21:23:50] <Dean Bogdanovic> well, it would be nice to have some proxies for them
[21:24:17] <Bert Wijnen> slide 9 again
[21:24:43] cabo joins the room
[21:26:18] <Bert Wijnen> Now we talk about issue "asymmetric document structure
[21:29:27] <Dean Bogdanovic> aj
[21:29:33] <Dean Bogdanovic> Im for it
[21:30:43] <Bert Wijnen> slides: http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/90/slides/slides-90-netconf-3.pdf
[21:30:49] <Bert Wijnen> now on slide 3
[21:30:56] <Bert Wijnen> Thanks Dean
[21:31:50] <Bert Wijnen> slide 4
[21:33:52] <Bert Wijnen> slide 5
[21:36:24] <Bert Wijnen> slide 6
[21:37:38] Joe Clarke leaves the room
[21:38:00] simona x joins the room
[21:41:10] <Bert Wijnen> slide 7
[21:42:11] simona x leaves the room
[21:42:56] Praveen Kumar leaves the room
[21:44:05] simona x joins the room
[21:45:16] <Bert Wijnen> slide numbers are now announced by speaker andy. SO we are on 9 now
[21:48:51] simona x leaves the room
[21:50:27] Mikael Abrahamsson leaves the room
[21:51:34] <Dean Bogdanovic> I agree that we need info service that includes extensions
[21:51:37] tom nadeau leaves the room
[21:55:00] <Dean Bogdanovic> Question: Will RESTCONF also support HTTP PATCH method?
[21:56:16] <Bert Wijnen> Sorry Dean I was in room away from latop
[21:56:38] <Bert Wijnen> can you mail your question to wg mlist?
[21:56:59] <Bert Wijnen> iirc the HTTP PATCH method was/is prereq, but I am not 100% sure
[21:57:05] <Dean Bogdanovic> will do
[21:57:09] <Dean Bogdanovic> no problem
[21:57:31] <Dean Bogdanovic> I thought so too that PATCH is required, so don't understand why PATCH is needed for YANG
[22:01:05] Sudhir Pendse leaves the room
[22:01:44] jeferson.nobre joins the room
[22:02:09] <Bert Wijnen> slide 8
[22:02:20] <Bert Wijnen> slide 9
[22:02:53] <Bert Wijnen> slide 10
[22:03:14] <Bert Wijnen> slide 9
[22:03:18] <Bert Wijnen> slide 10
[22:03:40] <Bert Wijnen> slide 11
[22:06:12] <Bert Wijnen> slide 12
[22:06:33] <Bert Wijnen> slide 13: Questions?
[22:07:28] <Bert Wijnen> slides: http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/90/slides/slides-90-netconf-8.pptx
[22:07:42] <Bert Wijnen> Jeff Haas (co-ciar of I2RS WG)
[22:08:03] <Dean Bogdanovic> First, I would prefer RESTCONF to be used with I2RS, not NETCONF
[22:08:08] <Dean Bogdanovic> few comments
[22:08:40] <Dean Bogdanovic> and with RESTCONF each POST/PUT/PATCH transaction can be inclusive of COMMIT
[22:10:16] <Dean Bogdanovic> I2RS is per device
[22:10:19] <Dean Bogdanovic> not per network
[22:10:41] <Bert Wijnen> I will read this at mic
[22:14:07] <Dean Bogdanovic> it is an overlay to the full data store
[22:15:31] <Dean Bogdanovic> I volunteer to write up that draft
[22:15:38] <Dean Bogdanovic> for the RESTCONF
[22:17:44] <Bert Wijnen> now: http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/90/slides/slides-90-netconf-6.ppt
[22:17:54] <Bert Wijnen> slide 2
[22:18:31] malleus.errata joins the room
[22:18:55] <Bert Wijnen> slide 3
[22:19:22] malleus.errata leaves the room
[22:20:05] <Bert Wijnen> slide 4
[22:20:53] <Bert Wijnen> Dean pls send your vulteering statement to mlist as well. Alwasy good to know
[22:21:01] <Bert Wijnen> slide 5
[22:21:41] <Bert Wijnen> slide 6
[22:22:20] <Bert Wijnen> slide 8
[22:29:17] <Bert Wijnen> slides: http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/90/slides/slides-90-netconf-7.pptx
[22:29:22] <Bert Wijnen> slide 1
[22:29:38] <Bert Wijnen> slide 2
[22:30:10] <Bert Wijnen> slide 3
[22:32:46] <Bert Wijnen> slide 4
[22:34:07] <Bert Wijnen> slide 5
[22:35:31] ida leung leaves the room
[22:35:32] Joe Clarke joins the room
[22:43:54] Dean Bogdanovic leaves the room
[22:43:54] room feed leaves the room
[22:44:06] Jürgen Schönwälder leaves the room
[22:44:10] alessandro amirante leaves the room
[22:44:14] Bert Wijnen leaves the room
[22:44:14] Giles Heron leaves the room
[22:44:19] Paolo Saviano leaves the room
[22:44:25] slide monitor leaves the room
[22:47:05] cabo leaves the room
[22:52:42] jeferson.nobre leaves the room
[23:18:36] cabo joins the room
[23:27:36] cabo leaves the room