IETF
eman@jabber.ietf.org
Tuesday, 27 March 2012< ^ >
Room Configuration

GMT+0
[11:05:44] Brian Trammell joins the room
[11:05:52] Brian Trammell leaves the room
[11:06:05] benoit.claise joins the room
[11:07:06] Brian Trammell joins the room
[11:08:28] tsavo_work@jabber.org/Meebo joins the room
[11:10:33] <Brian Trammell> slide "revised relationships"
[11:10:50] <Brian Trammell> slide "revised: energy object relationship"
[11:11:17] <Brian Trammell> slide "...all other..."
[11:11:54] <benoit.claise> John Parello has some difficulties to join jabber. He will provide his feedback inside the webex chat.
[11:12:35] tsavo_work@jabber.org/Meebo leaves the room
[11:15:14] tsavo_work@jabber.org/Meebo joins the room
[11:15:43] <Brian Trammell> slide "Term: Power Quality"
[11:16:03] <Brian Trammell> (slides are at http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/83/slides/slides-83-eman-1.pdf )
[11:19:38] <Brian Trammell> slide: Summary
[11:23:27] <Brian Trammell> slide deck: requiremenrts for energy management, http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/83/slides/slides-83-eman-2.pdf
[11:23:32] <benoit.claise> from john parello to Everyone:
THanks Nevil!!!
[11:23:59] <Brian Trammell> slide 1
[11:24:14] <Brian Trammell> slide
[11:24:16] <Brian Trammell> 2
[11:24:36] <Brian Trammell> slide 3
[11:29:54] apelov@gmail.com joins the room
[11:31:05] <Brian Trammell> slide 4
[11:34:14] rolf.winter joins the room
[11:34:23] gigix73 joins the room
[11:37:23] John Parello joins the room
[11:38:31] <John Parello> Thank you Nevil for the Definition presentation
[11:40:13] <John Parello> IMO the requirements should state that power and energy should be measured in intervals for both meter and devices. How is up to solutions.
[11:40:37] bschoeni joins the room
[11:43:55] <Brian Trammell> slide 5
[11:45:09] <Brian Trammell> benoit is presenting http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/83/slides/slides-83-eman-3.pdf
[11:47:07] <Brian Trammell> slide charter / abstract
[11:47:43] <Brian Trammell> slide changes in 4/5
[11:48:45] benoit.claise leaves the room
[11:49:29] <Brian Trammell> next slide (2nd changes in 4/5 slide)
[11:50:22] benoit.claise joins the room
[11:50:24] <Brian Trammell> slide information model (part 1)
[11:51:56] <Brian Trammell> slide information model (part 2)
[11:52:26] <Brian Trammell> (indicating relationships are UUID lists)
[11:54:46] <Brian Trammell> next slide
[11:54:53] <Brian Trammell> (changes in version 4 and 5)
[11:55:08] <Brian Trammell> slide current open issues part 1
[12:01:09] <Brian Trammell> slide uuid representation
[12:02:01] <Brian Trammell> slide multiple URIs
[12:02:10] <Brian Trammell> (not yet)
[12:02:32] <Brian Trammell> question to John: how large are the URI lists (typical/max)
[12:02:33] <John Parello> We've seen noless than 100 no more than that
[12:02:42] <John Parello> sorry no more than 100 ever
[12:03:16] <John Parello> avg is around 10-20
[12:03:58] <Brian Trammell> okay, now slide multiple URIs
[12:04:02] <Brian Trammell> (thanks, John)
[12:06:58] <Brian Trammell> skip to conclusion
[12:08:01] <Brian Trammell> now benoit presents http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/83/slides/slides-83-eman-4.pdf
[12:09:14] <Brian Trammell> slide new: merge
[12:10:03] <Brian Trammell> slide new: feedback
[12:11:38] <Brian Trammell> slide new: merge: power interface
[12:12:25] <Brian Trammell> slide: physical devices
[12:13:15] <Brian Trammell> slide: power interface clarification
[12:14:01] <Brian Trammell> slide: example 1
[12:14:49] <Brian Trammell> (this = "no interfaces")
[12:15:01] <Brian Trammell> slide: example 2
[12:16:10] <Brian Trammell> next slide: new: sections 6.4...
[12:17:56] <Brian Trammell> slide: more open issues
[12:27:56] <John Parello> Just to note. In building management systems there are three types of device discussed here. Power distribution devices, meters and aggregation devices. Aggregation devices are things like Lutron lighting controllers, Schneider electric gateways. These are physical devices. So why not acknowledge that and model them.
[12:33:13] <Brian Trammell> http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/83/slides/slides-83-eman-5.pdf
[12:33:22] <Brian Trammell> first slide: what's new
[12:36:10] <Brian Trammell> slide: IANA: process for deprecation
[12:37:00] <Brian Trammell> slide: open issue 1
[12:37:59] <Brian Trammell> slide: open issue 2
[12:38:59] <Brian Trammell> slide: open issue 3
[12:39:58] <Brian Trammell> open issue 4
[12:40:55] <Brian Trammell> open issue 7
[12:42:11] gigix73 leaves the room
[12:43:48] <Brian Trammell> open issue 9
[12:43:57] <Brian Trammell> (not yet)
[12:44:43] <Brian Trammell> (now open issue 9)
[12:45:23] <Brian Trammell> slide: summary
[12:46:47] rolf.winter leaves the room
[12:46:51] rolf.winter joins the room
[12:47:08] <Brian Trammell> rolf is presenting http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/83/slides/slides-83-eman-6.pdf
[12:47:15] <Brian Trammell> slide: since the last meeting
[12:48:13] <Brian Trammell> slide: open issues
[12:53:08] <Brian Trammell> mouli presents: http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/83/slides/slides-83-eman-7.pdf
[12:53:14] <Brian Trammell> first slide: what is new
[12:53:29] rolf.winter leaves the room: Replaced by new connection
[12:53:30] rolf.winter joins the room
[12:53:36] tsavo_work@jabber.org/Meebo leaves the room
[12:53:42] <Brian Trammell> skip to open issue 1
[12:54:39] <Brian Trammell> next slide open issue 2
[12:55:48] rolf.winter leaves the room
[12:56:00] rolf.winter joins the room
[12:57:54] <John Parello> To the ASHRAE point - We have one fixed field which is the Nameplate (Maximal) power. If there's more fields we need we can surely add them.
[13:02:05] <Brian Trammell> slide: open issue 4
[13:03:17] apelov@gmail.com leaves the room
[13:04:04] Brian Trammell leaves the room
[13:04:31] rolf.winter leaves the room
[13:04:58] John Parello leaves the room
[13:35:26] benoit.claise leaves the room
[13:51:38] rolf.winter joins the room
[13:51:59] rolf.winter leaves the room
[13:52:06] rolf.winter joins the room
[14:08:47] rolf.winter leaves the room
[18:51:09] bschoeni leaves the room