IETF
clue@jabber.ietf.org
Thursday, 28 July 2011< ^ >
stpeter has set the subject to: CLUE WG | http://tools.ietf.org/wg/clue/
Room Configuration

GMT+0
[12:49:27] MeetechoAudioFeed joins the room
[12:50:47] Lorenzo Miniero joins the room
[12:51:12] MeetechoSpromano joins the room
[12:51:48] MeetechoSlides joins the room
[12:53:33] Stephane Proust joins the room
[12:54:41] tomkrist joins the room
[12:55:24] patrick Mourot joins the room
[12:55:26] Tom Kristensen joins the room
[12:55:47] admin joins the room
[12:55:47] admin leaves the room
[12:56:52] MeetechoAlex joins the room
[12:58:02] Stephane Proust leaves the room
[12:58:03] <MeetechoSlides> Status and agenda bash: Chairs
Meetecho session is at http://www.meetecho.com/ietf81/clue
Slides are at http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/81/slides/clue-2.pdf
[12:58:18] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 1: CLUE WG IETF-81
[12:58:23] martin.thomson joins the room
[12:58:27] Stephane Proust joins the room
[12:58:36] <Lorenzo Miniero> RTSP stream to those who may be interested is at rtsp://conf.meetecho.com/5553569.sdp
[12:58:44] stpeter joins the room
[12:59:15] <stpeter> I shall be your jabber proxy, if you want comments to be fed to the microphone please preface with "MIC"
[12:59:26] Jonathan Lennox joins the room
[12:59:36] suzukisn joins the room
[13:00:06] martin.thomson leaves the room
[13:00:16] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 2: Note Well
[13:00:19] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 3: Agenda – Thursday 0900-1130
[13:00:43] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 4: Way Forward
[13:00:49] <MeetechoSlides> Presentation stopped
[13:00:52] patrick Mourot leaves the room
[13:00:59] <MeetechoSlides> Definitions - open issues (Stephan Wenger)
Meetecho session is at http://www.meetecho.com/ietf81/clue
Slides are at http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/81/slides/clue-3.pptx
[13:01:22] Xavier Marjou joins the room
[13:01:22] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 1: CLUE definitions
[13:01:34] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 2: Document Usefulness
[13:01:40] bpenfield joins the room
[13:02:57] stpeter has set the subject to: CLUE WG | http://tools.ietf.org/wg/clue/ | IETF 81 | audio at http://ietf81streaming.dnsalias.net/ietf/ietf804.m3u | slides at https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/81/materials.html#wg-clue
[13:03:38] patrick Mourot joins the room
[13:04:52] Leon Portman joins the room
[13:05:51] laiyemo joins the room
[13:07:01] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 3: Open issue #1: left/right
[13:08:22] Leon Portman leaves the room
[13:08:58] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 4: Open issue #2: Layout
[13:09:27] laiyemo leaves the room
[13:10:13] Andy Hutton joins the room
[13:11:48] Stephane Proust leaves the room
[13:12:11] Stephane Proust joins the room
[13:12:12] tomkrist leaves the room: Disconnected.
[13:12:12] tomkrist joins the room
[13:12:17] Tom Kristensen leaves the room
[13:12:39] tomkrist leaves the room: Disconnected.
[13:12:44] tomkrist joins the room
[13:13:16] Andy Hutton leaves the room
[13:13:23] Tom Kristensen joins the room
[13:15:02] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 5: Open Issue #3: MCU
[13:18:23] laiyemo joins the room
[13:19:48] burn joins the room
[13:22:32] laiyemo leaves the room
[13:22:50] bpenfield leaves the room
[13:23:20] laiyemo joins the room
[13:24:37] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 6: Open Issue #4: Media
[13:28:40] <MeetechoSlides> Presentation stopped
[13:29:02] <MeetechoSlides> Rendering Type Negotiation (Christer Holmberg)
Meetecho session is at http://www.meetecho.com/ietf81/clue
Slides are at http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/81/slides/clue-4.ppt
[13:29:05] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 1: Rendering advertisement and selection
[13:29:22] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 2: DEFINITION
[13:33:13] RjS joins the room
[13:33:47] hta joins the room
[13:33:57] Xavier Marjou leaves the room
[13:34:21] <hta> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cement_render
[13:34:52] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 3: USAGE
[13:35:00] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 4: EXAMPLE: Binaural audio
[13:35:59] Xavier Marjou joins the room
[13:38:03] eburger joins the room
[13:38:11] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 2: DEFINITION
[13:38:26] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 4: EXAMPLE: Binaural audio
[13:40:21] bpenfield joins the room
[13:40:36] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 5: EXAMPLE: 2 most active speakers
[13:41:38] laiyemo leaves the room
[13:43:32] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 6: QUESTION
[13:44:49] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 7: RETRIEVED REQUIREMENTS
[13:45:45] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 8: THANK YOU FOR LISTENING!
[13:45:51] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 7: RETRIEVED REQUIREMENTS
[13:46:25] <MeetechoSlides> Presentation stopped
[13:46:33] <MeetechoSlides> Requirements (Allyn Romanow)
Meetecho session is at http://www.meetecho.com/ietf81/clue
Slides are at http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/81/slides/clue-0.pptx
[13:46:44] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 1: CLUE IETF-81 July 2011
[13:47:07] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 2: Proposed changes for draft .04
[13:47:28] Jonathan Lennox leaves the room
[13:47:33] Jonathan Lennox joins the room
[13:48:17] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 3: (no title)
[13:49:36] <MeetechoSlides> Reqmt-3a
[13:54:49] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 4: (no title)
[13:55:00] eburger leaves the room
[13:55:05] <MeetechoSlides> Reqmt - 3b
[13:55:44] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 5: (no title)
[13:55:52] <MeetechoSlides> Reqmt 7
[13:57:27] <MeetechoSlides> Reqmt 8
[13:59:25] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 6: (no title)
[13:59:37] <MeetechoSlides> Reqmt 10
[14:02:10] Roberto Bifulco joins the room
[14:03:01] Roy joins the room
[14:03:12] Gonzalo joins the room
[14:03:26] Robet Sparks joins the room
[14:06:57] eburger joins the room
[14:08:56] Robert Sparks joins the room
[14:10:41] <eburger> quiet chat room
[14:11:06] <MeetechoSpromano> :-)
[14:11:30] <Tom Kristensen> Requirement overflow in chat room ;-)
[14:11:42] <eburger> Just seeing if anyone is awake. At least Simon is ;-)
[14:12:11] <MeetechoSpromano> I MUST be...you SHOULD!
[14:12:11] <MeetechoSlides> :)
[14:16:42] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 7: (no title)
[14:19:55] <hta> Nobody's awake.
[14:19:59] <eburger> zzzz
[14:20:30] <RjS> I need a protocol that would let me affect where the camera that is covering the microphone lines is pointing
[14:21:11] <RjS> I think the camera position they've chosen for this meeting is truly unfortunate
[14:21:13] <hta> REQMT-YY: The solution MUST make it possible to tell the cameraman where to point the camera (when there is one)
[14:22:03] Gonzalo leaves the room
[14:22:53] Massimo Fattorusso joins the room
[14:23:41] <MeetechoSpromano> We definitely need more cameramen!
[14:23:56] <MeetechoSpromano> looking for volunteers...
[14:24:02] <MeetechoSlides> :)
[14:24:10] <MeetechoAlex> :)
[14:24:25] <hta> talking about camera control in CLUE is kind of self-referential :-)
[14:25:57] eburger leaves the room
[14:28:01] <MeetechoSlides> Presentation stopped
[14:28:17] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 1: CLUE Framework
[14:28:54] <MeetechoSlides> Framework
Meetecho session is at http://www.meetecho.com/ietf81/clue
Slides are at http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/81/slides/clue-1.pptx
[14:29:00] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 2: Multiple Media Streams
[14:29:13] Massimo Fattorusso leaves the room
[14:29:20] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 3: Challenges
[14:29:24] <Tom Kristensen> Is the mic still used/working?
[14:29:35] paul erkkila joins the room
[14:29:37] Bob Penfield joins the room
[14:29:41] <Tom Kristensen> Thanks!
[14:29:52] <MeetechoSpromano> She was not usimg it at all..
[14:29:57] <Tom Kristensen> Aha :-)
[14:30:09] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 4: What’s Needed?
[14:30:43] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 5: Process
[14:31:33] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 6: Structure of Information
[14:32:38] Roberto Bifulco leaves the room
[14:33:44] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 7: Media Capture Description
[14:33:56] <MeetechoSlides> Framework (Mark Duckworth)
Meetecho session is at http://www.meetecho.com/ietf81/clue
Slides are at http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/81/slides/clue-1.pptx
[14:34:03] hta leaves the room
[14:34:12] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 8: Media Capture
[14:34:29] hta joins the room
[14:34:33] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 9: Attributes
[14:35:51] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 8: Media Capture
[14:36:02] Massimo Fattorusso joins the room
[14:36:30] <MeetechoAlex> is the volume level ok?
[14:36:31] bpenfield leaves the room
[14:36:35] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 9: Attributes
[14:36:46] <MeetechoAlex> we can raise it if needed...
[14:37:04] <Tom Kristensen> My local volume is at max, so may raise it a bit :-)
[14:37:59] <MeetechoSpromano> Much better, now.
[14:38:03] <Tom Kristensen> Indeed
[14:38:26] <MeetechoAlex> ;)
[14:38:53] Massimo Fattorusso leaves the room
[14:39:43] <paul erkkila> Slides are slightly diff in the room :-)
[14:39:49] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 10: Capture Scene
[14:39:53] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 9: Attributes
[14:40:17] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 10: Capture Scene
[14:42:23] Bob Penfield leaves the room
[14:44:02] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 11: Capture Set
[14:50:10] stpeter leaves the room
[14:50:10] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 12: Video Capture Adjacency
[14:53:14] paul erkkila leaves the room
[14:55:43] Andy Hutton joins the room
[14:59:09] stpeter joins the room
[14:59:59] Andy Hutton leaves the room
[15:00:30] burn leaves the room
[15:01:47] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 13: Matching Audio with Video
[15:02:24] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 14: Matching Audio with Video
[15:09:28] paul erkkila joins the room
[15:10:43] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 15: Choosing Streams
[15:10:54] <MeetechoSlides> Framework (Andy Pepperell)
Meetecho session is at http://www.meetecho.com/ietf81/clue
Slides are at http://www.ietf.org/proceedings/81/slides/clue-1.pptx
[15:10:56] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 16: Basic message flow
[15:12:26] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 17: Capabilities Sent by Consumer
[15:14:29] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 18: Advertisement Sent by Provider
[15:14:59] paul erkkila leaves the room
[15:15:45] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 19: Configure Msg Sent by Consumer
[15:17:56] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 20: Provider Capture Advertisement
[15:18:32] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 21: Simultaneous Transmission Sets
[15:22:02] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 22: Encoding Groups
[15:24:34] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 23: Encoding Group Structure
[15:25:20] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 24: Video Encode Attributes
[15:26:01] <MeetechoSlides> Slide 25: Sample Encoding Group
[15:29:40] hta leaves the room
[15:31:00] RjS leaves the room
[15:31:04] Jonathan Lennox leaves the room
[15:31:04] patrick Mourot leaves the room
[15:31:35] MeetechoAlex leaves the room
[15:31:36] MeetechoSpromano leaves the room
[15:31:37] stpeter leaves the room
[15:31:44] Robet Sparks leaves the room
[15:31:44] Robert Sparks leaves the room
[15:31:58] suzukisn leaves the room
[15:32:03] <Tom Kristensen> Thanks and good afternoon
[15:32:10] Xavier Marjou leaves the room
[15:32:14] Lorenzo Miniero leaves the room
[15:32:35] <MeetechoAudioFeed> Bye
[15:32:38] MeetechoSlides leaves the room
[15:32:38] MeetechoAudioFeed leaves the room
[15:33:05] Tom Kristensen leaves the room
[15:33:56] Stephane Proust leaves the room
[15:34:05] tomkrist leaves the room: Disconnected.
[15:41:15] Pablo Allietti joins the room
[15:42:20] Roy leaves the room
[15:42:56] Roy joins the room
[15:44:26] Pablo Allietti leaves the room
[16:01:41] Roy leaves the room
[16:58:52] RjS joins the room
[16:59:00] RjS leaves the room
[17:00:38] Jonathan Lennox joins the room
[17:02:54] Jonathan Lennox leaves the room
[17:08:31] martin.thomson joins the room
[17:10:03] martin.thomson leaves the room
[17:13:21] burn joins the room
[18:56:43] burn leaves the room
[19:19:29] burn joins the room
[19:25:18] martin.thomson joins the room
[19:27:20] martin.thomson leaves the room
[20:41:26] burn leaves the room