[14:21:24] lars@eggert.org joins the room [14:21:40] Lee Howard joins the room [14:25:44] jlc2John joins the room [14:27:13] oak joins the room [14:27:48] Ted Lemon joins the room [14:27:59] Ted Lemon leaves the room [14:29:07] rscheff joins the room [14:29:29] aqm recommendations, slide "next steps" [14:33:39] ECN benefits slide [14:33:48] Benefit from avoiding congestion loss [14:35:37] Benefits that require special configuration [14:36:01] in case anyone wants to help write minutes: http://etherpad.tools.ietf.org:9000/p/notes-ietf-89-aqm [14:37:23] conclusion [14:37:51] RoadRunner joins the room [14:38:03] next steps [14:45:58] MIC: this draft is very helpful; for discussion; we need to balance against problems; I could suggest some other benefits offline; the unasked question is whether it belongs in this WG. [14:48:46] i tried to bring up the Q if this belongs to this WG; [14:51:46] Have we given up on names at the mic? [14:51:58] andrew mcgregor [14:53:45] dave robinson [14:53:45] dirk kutcher [14:54:31] Stuart Cheshire [14:54:32] steward cheschire [14:56:23] will somebody make stuart post those instructions to the list... please!! [14:56:50] they will appear in the minutes, [14:57:02] and i ask him to post them too,.. [14:58:24] cheshire joins the room [14:58:26] Since the line was closed: Some considerations are not included because they depend on confguration. This is a sales document; and engineering document describing tradeoffs would be more useful. [14:58:53] Enabling ECN on Mac OS X: [14:59:05] sudo sysctl -w net.inet.tcp.ecn_initiate_out=1 sudo sysctl -w net.inet.tcp.ecn_negotiate_in=1 [15:01:23] AQM eval guidelines [15:01:24] slide 2 [15:01:44] slide 3 [15:02:25] slide 4 - context [15:03:15] slide 5 - objectives [15:03:53] slide 7 - metrics [15:04:28] slide 8 - queue related metrics [15:05:53] will someone ask about multiple queues? [15:07:41] scott bradner [15:09:43] Fred Baker joins the room [15:10:42] rong pan [15:12:27] michael scharf (last Q) [15:12:32] RoadRunner leaves the room [15:12:53] Gabriel Zigelboim joins the room [15:12:53] fred baker [15:14:55] slide 9 - end 2 end etrics [15:18:40] slide 11 - evaluation scenarios [15:19:46] slide 12 - methodology [15:20:13] Wolfgang Beck joins the room [15:20:37] slide 13 - topology [15:21:38] al morton [15:22:30] slide 14 - generic scenarios [15:23:58] why is TCP cubic considered aggressive? doesn't it degenerate to TCP Reno in the presence of real TCP Reno? [15:25:23] slide - performance evaluation [15:32:35] lee howard [15:33:30] Nameed [15:34:24] rong pan [15:36:11] lars eggert [15:38:14] dave täht [15:39:24] rong pan [15:40:24] lars eggert [15:40:46] nameed [15:41:32] rong pan [15:43:34] michael lee (?) [15:44:06] dave nielsen (?) [15:45:56] jana [15:48:09] Lee Howard leaves the room [15:48:15] dave täth [15:50:19] jana [15:51:28] lars@eggert.org leaves the room [15:51:31] cheshire leaves the room [15:51:54] Wolfgang Beck leaves the room [15:52:26] jlc2John leaves the room [15:54:43] rscheff leaves the room [15:58:24] Fred Baker leaves the room [16:03:53] oak leaves the room [16:04:35] nichols joins the room [16:09:01] nichols leaves the room [16:10:42] lars@eggert.org joins the room [16:11:04] lars@eggert.org leaves the room [16:14:51] Fred Baker joins the room [16:15:18] Fred Baker leaves the room [16:15:24] cheshire joins the room [16:32:12] Gabriel Zigelboim leaves the room [16:52:27] Lee Howard joins the room [16:55:28] Lee Howard leaves the room [17:05:44] Lee Howard joins the room [17:39:17] Lee Howard leaves the room [17:42:09] Lee Howard joins the room [17:43:33] Lee Howard leaves the room [17:43:49] Lee Howard joins the room [18:28:36] Lee Howard leaves the room [18:59:26] cheshire leaves the room [23:47:10] cheshire joins the room